Item 1

Motion from Councillor Dermot Lacey

This Committee requests the Manager to arrange a clean up and tidy up of the old graveyard adjacent to the Tara Towers Hotel and in particular to arrange to have the offensive graffiti removed from various head stones and a programme of action to save some of the broken head stones that are now scattered around.

Report

A clean up of the graveyard will be undertaken over the coming week to bring the site up to the required standard of maintenance. There was no evidence of graffiti on the gravestones however there was evidence of lichen and fungal growth which is normal for such old headstones. I propose to arrange a meeting with the City Archeologist and the heritage officer in the near future to discuss how to deal with the headstones using national ‘best practice’.

Item 2

Motion from Councillor Dermot Lacey

To ask the Manager, further to numerous previous questions from this Councillor on the last City Council, what arrangements have now been agreed with the owners at Milltown Park, Ranelagh in relation to the decision on P.A. 5393/06 and An Bord Pleanala decision PL 29S.221293 condition number 1 requiring “agreement in writing with the Planning Authority on appropriate measures to restrict access to emergency services and deliveries only” and in the event of such an agreement being in place to provide a copy to this Councillor and to outline how it is enforced. If such a written agreement is not in place to clarify how the development was allowed to proceed and to outline what steps will now be taken to enforce the relevant condition.

Report

Planning permission was granted on 23 May 2007 for the demolition of Cherryfield Nursing Home at Milltown Park, Ranelagh, Dublin 6 and the development of a new Nursing Home and accommodation building at Milltown Park, Ranelagh, Dublin 6 (planning register reference 5393/06 refers).

Condition 1 of the permission stated

“Access onto Cherryfield Avenue shall be restricted to emergency services and deliveries only. Details of appropriate measures to restrict access shall be agreed in writing with the planning authority prior to the commencement of development.

Reason: To clarify the permission and in the interest of traffic safety and proper planning and sustainable development.”

Following receipt of a complaint that this condition had not been complied with, a Warning Letter pursuant to Section 152 of the Planning and Development Act 2000 was served on the property owners. In response, proposals to comply with the condition were submitted on 6 June 2008. These were deemed in compliance with the requirements of the permission on 11 July 2008.

Regular monitoring by the Area Enforcement Officer through 2008 and 2009 has not shown any evidence of use of this access outside the terms of the permission. Nor has there been any complaints received of unauthorised use.

Compliance details were received on June 6th, 2008 in respect of Condition Number 1 attached to a grant of permission under An Bord Pleanala ref PL.29S.221293.

Scott Tallon Walker Architects confirmed arrangements for access to the nursing home and to the site during construction phases. On completion of this development they confirmed that access to the Milltown development will be from the main Milltown road. Access from Cherryfield Avenue was to be restricted by a mechanically operated gated system, to emergencies and deliveries only. The Architects have also submitted an ‘as built’ drawing showing the current arrangements.

The Planning Enforcement Section dealt with a complaint regarding alleged unauthorised use of Cherryfield Avenue in February 2008 during construction of this development. There have been no complaints submitted to this Department since then.

Item 3

Motion from Councillor Dermot Lacey

To ask the Manager to ensure the reinstatement of the Disc parking spaces at 38, 40, 62 and 64 Heytesbury Lane removed during road works in 2008 and on which a commitment was given that they would be replaced on numerous occasions since, including a formal reply to this Councillor in January 2009 and on which no subsequent action has been taken

Report

This matter has been referred to the Area Traffic Officer for inspection and when his report is received a detailed report will be provided to the Councillor.

If you have a matter that you’d like raised at the monthly City Council or Area Committee meetings, please let me know.

2009 has been one of the most dynamic years in a long time. Labour in Dublin built on our previous successes with no small contribution from Dublin South East. In Pembroke –Rathmines winning three seats was quite simply unprecedented and allied to Maria and Kevin winning in the South East Inner City was a tribute to the hard work of a lot of people over many years. Since June we have sought to deliver on many fronts on the City Council where Labour is indisputably leading the way. Work on the Council since June has centered on the Draft Development Plan and the adoption of the Budget for 2010.

Pembroke-Rathmines

In addition to getting to know the newer (for me) parts of the ward I was particularly delighted to see the Affordable/Social Houses in Beech Hill I initiated finally completed and that improvement works have continued in Herbert Park. Planning and traffic issues have dominated over the year with the former Jury’s/Berkely Court and RTE sites a major focus. It is increasingly clear to me that there must be fundamental reform of our planning laws to facilitate more pre-application dialogue. Devolution of traffic responsibility must be part of any genuine Local Government reform.

City Council

Following the elections I was re-appointed to the Dublin Regional Authority, the Southern and Eastern Regional Assembly and the VEC. I was also appointed to the Association of City and County Councils, the Commissioners of Irish Lights and the Protocol and Finance Committees of the City Council. I hope to be able to use all of these in pursuit of local and city wide improvements. I have continued my work as Chairperson of the South Inner City Local Drugs Task Force and more recently I have been invited to serve on the Board of the Royal Hospital Donnybrook Voluntary Housing Association. On the latter I am presently developing a very positive housing initiative and will report to the Council when there are further details.

Thanks

A lot of people gave me a lot of help over the year, thanks in the first place are due to Aidan Sweeny and Gerry Ashe who ran my re-election campaign, all the members in Pembroke –Rathmines and particularly my colleagues in the Donnybrook Branch who came out so often, deserve and get, my heartfelt thanks. Denise, Gerry and Ian in Leinster House who do far more than any of you will ever believe. Working with Ruairi, Mary, Oisin, Kevin and Maria makes life interesting to say the least and I believe together we have made a difference. Special “thanks” must go to Jill for her support. “One year on one page” – that was the request from the Executive – Thanks to you all. I believe it has been worth it. Hope you do too?

Black & Brown Bins
There will be no collection on Christmas Day.  Bins due to be collected on Christmas Day will instead be collected on Saturday 26th December.
There will also be no collection on New Year’s Day.  Bins due to be collected on New Year’s Day will instead by collected on Saturday 2nd January.  So, if you have a Friday collection, remember it’s moving to Saturday for the next two weeks.

Green Bins
At this time of year, many of us have more recyclable materials than usual.  All that wrapping paper and packaging from toys should be recycled too!  Because of this, we’ve arranged to allow you to put additional recyclable materials tidily beside your Green Bin once it’s full, and those will be collected too.  this service will last until 15th January to ensure you’ve plenty of time to clean up after the festivities!

Bottle Banks
Unmanned bottle banks will remain open over Christmas, and will be emptied on a regular basis.  Please remember not to leave rubbish lying around after you’ve put your bottles safely in the bin.  Bring the plastic bags or cardboard boxes back home for your Green Bin.

Bring Centres & Recycling Centres
Bring Centres, such as Herzog Park on Orwell Road, Rathgar, will have shorter opening hours during the Christmas season.  They will be closed on Christmas Eve, Christmas Day, St Stephen’s Day, New Year’s Eve and New Year’s Day.  On 27th & 28th December, they’ll be open from 10am to 4pm, and on 29th & 30th December, they’ll be open from 9am to 4pm.  On January 2nd, they’ll be open from 10am to 4pm, and will then revert to their normal hours.

Recycling Centres, such as the Pigeon House Road Depot in Ringsend, will be closed on the same days and will otherwise open from 9am to 5pm Monday to Friday and 9am to 2pm on Saturdays over the Christmas season.

Christmas Tree Recycling
Finally, that will bring us up to December 8th, and it’ll be time to take down the tree.  Free Christmas Tree recycling will be available from 2nd to 20th January.  Opening hours will be the same as our normal bring centre hours.  The locations in our area are:

• Gulistan Terrace, Rathmines
• Milltown Car Park, Milltown Road
• Martello Tower Car Park, Strand Road, Sandymount

You can get the full rundown of all this information, and more details if required, at DublinWaste.ie.

Have a happy Christmas.

At Labour Party level we have see the successful conclusion of the Lisbon Referendum campaign, the first meeting of the new Central Council and the continued leadership of the Opposition of Eamonn Gilmore.

Locally I have met with residents groups in Harolds Cross, Milltown, Rathgar, Donnybrook and Rathmines and attended the Annual General Meeting of the Sandymount and Merrion Residents Association. The latter is always a good opportunity to meet old friends and review events since the year before. This year the madness of the division of Sandymount into two electoral areas was evidenced by the potential presence of fourteen elected representatives. I also attended the first AGM of the revitalized Beech Hill Community Association and congratulate the new Committee on doing such a good job.

Successes locally included the amazing Ranelagh Arts Festival and the completion of the new Social and Affordable Housing scheme in Beech Hill. As Chairperson of the School Committee I was very proud of the young people from St. Josephs Junior Education Centre in Milltown who did so well in their Junior Certificate. Given the difficulties these young people from the Traveller community experience in their daily lives this was a great personal achievement

Issues locally include the proposed rezoning of the car park at O’Sheas’ Pub in Clonskeagh to facilitate an Affordable Housing Scheme, the on –going saga of parking in St. Alban’s Park, the redevelopment of the Rathmines Swimming Pool and the implementation of the Rathmines Local Area Plan and the completion of the Rathgar Plan.

The proposed rezoning of the RTE lands is also a major issue and like my fellow Public Representatives for the area I have sought provision of a new site for St. Mary’s Belmont Avenue as part of the “community gain” element of any final agreement. This will be dealt with in the context of the new City Development Plan for which I am presently preparing a range of submissions.

In my work as Chairperson of the South Inner City Local Drugs Task Force I have continued to work with a large number of community groups across the area in the struggle for a better way of life for all affected by drugs –including the very professional launch of the Merchants Quay Project Annual Report. I also attended the annual “Getting a Grip” Conference on the issue in Killarney where I tackled the Minister for Drugs, John Curran TD on the high jacking by Government of Lottery Funds for purposes other than for which they were intended – i.e. community use.

In the media recently I have received coverage in the Sunday Business Post on housing matters, the Evening Herald and Southside on the redevelopment of the RTE lands, the Irish Times on Local Government reform. I have also been recently interviewed on both Dublin South Radio and NEAR FM. Last week I participated in a lively discussion on The Right Hook on the issue of Trade Union Leaders salaries and the role of Social Partnership.

Along side all of this, after five years membership of St. Mary’s Tennis Club I am finally taking lessons. Don’t think it’s a question of Wimbledon here I come but it is good to be out and enjoying the fun of the game.

Letters Page,

The Sunday Business Post.

Dear Editor,

What a pity that Jennifer O’Connell (SPB 18th October) should reduce a reasonably balanced piece about the need for good planning to a typically mean-spirited attack on those living in Council housing.

Thanks to the foresight of my predecessors as Dublin City Councillors my parents had the opportunity to secure a Council house and myself and my brothers and sisters a family home. That was more than fifty years ago. I don’t think that, we as a family have wreaked havoc on the area since. When I married myself and my wife, bought a house built by Dublin Corporation in, at that time, primarily a Council housing estate. Over the half century since the estate was built it has been a good place to raise many families and it is a good place to raise my children. The only other house I have lived in was The Mansion House in Dawson Street – surely one of the best Council provided homes in the country.

Yes, we need good planning and yes we need to provide a good mixture of housing types. Perhaps also we need to revert to an Ireland that saw housing as a human need rather than an investment opportunity.

Yours sincerely,

Councillor Dermot Lacey

“As we approach the publication of the proposed White Paper on Local Government there is an emerging recognition that our current system requires renewal and reform.

While the detail of any reform is extensive, the essentials are not. If it is to be in any way meaningful reform must include:

• An Independent source of funding for Local Authorities and not subject to the whims of the Department of the Environment.

• Reform of the City and County Managers Act creating a new post of Chief Executive Officer – accountable to the relevant Local Authority and recruited by the Public Appointments Commission.

• A directly elected Mayor of Dublin with a five year term and accountable to an enhanced Dublin Regional Authority. In that context I believe that it is wrong to advance the case of a directly elected Lord Mayor solely for the City. It is the Dublin region that needs such political leadership.

• Extending the role of the Dublin Regional Authority to include Transport and Planning and subsuming bodies such as the Dublin Transport Authority and the Affordable Housing Partnership.

• Real controls and limitations on electoral spending at local elections and an ethical framework that is robust and just.

Local Government is best placed to deliver real reform if let. It is time to stand up for better Local Government and long past time to “Stand up for Dublin.”

The next City Council meeting takes place on September 7th followed by the Area Committee on September 14th.

I have tabled a number of questions relating to the financial situation facing the Council and a suggestion that the Council would initiate an “Ideas for Dublin” Competition and Website.

On Friday last I participated on “Today with Pat Kenny” on the issue of Local Government reform along with Cllr George Jones of Fine Gael. I think it went well and Pat gave us both a fair innings.

It never rains but it pours and on Monday night I was on Newstalk 106 with Eoin O’Broin of Sinn Fein and Ruth Coppinger of the Socialist Party to debate the Future of the Left. This was followed the next day as I was on the morning show on 4FM (7.40am to be precise) to talk about the case for a directly elected Mayor for Dublin. Today I open up Southside to find a nice piece on the campaign to Save the Poolbeg Chimneys and arrive home to receive in the post the Aontas magazine featuring “a day in the life of – A Councillor” containing an article I had written a few months ago.

Next few weeks will see us out campaigning on Lisbon 2 and hopefully for the sake of the country there will be a resounding YES.

Local:

• Rathmines – Pembroke Partnership.
• Lansdowne Road Stadium – Project Monitoring Committee.
• Chairperson –South East Area Policing Committee.

I have also been recently invited to serve on the Board of the Royal Hospital Donnybrook Voluntary Housing Association.

City Council:

• City Council Audit Committee.
• Finance and General Strategic Policy Committee.
• Protocol and Selection Committee.

Dublin:

• City of Dublin VEC
• Dublin Regional Authority

National:

• Association of City and County Councils
• Southern and Eastern Regional Assembly
• Irish Public Bodies Mutual Insurance.
• Commissioners of Irish Lights

Over the coming years I hope to use my membership of these various bodies to represent the best interests of the Pembroke-Rathmines and of Dublin generally and to advance the various issues to which I am committed. I hope also to use this website to provide regular reports, where appropriate on these.

“While the text of RTE’s submission to the Draft City Development Plan has been released following a formal request submitted by me that is all it is – a submission.

By and large the local community has accepted RTE’s expansion beyond the initial Montrose complex and despite the lack of any real neighbourly relationship the community has not in any way impeded RTE’s use of the site.

However the attempt to change the Zoning from Z15 Institutional and Community use to Z10 that would allow “for mixed use development on which office, retail and residential would be the predominant use” would be a major challenge to the interests of the local area and will have to be examined in huge detail before any such rezoning could be contemplated.

The current RTE complex covers the original Montrose House estate (once home to the Jameson Family and at one stage lived in by Marconi the reputed inventor of radio), the former Sports Grounds of St. Andrews College in whose outdoor Swimming pool I swam as a child and parts of the Belville and other lands.

Given the importance of the new City Development Plan for the future wellbeing of Dublin it is heartening to see the National Broadcaster take such an interest in this. It will be even more heartening if this is followed up by an ongoing coverage of the Development Plan process to facilitate the greatest possible engagement of the people of Dublin in developing the Plan”